Please select Witch Ends first.
- Cauldron Special
- $27.00
- late nights call for the best brownies
- Take-Out Box* filled with 4 Fat, 3 Blonde,
3 Caramel Babies.
- color of box and ribbon may vary. Shipment only -
No Store Pick Up.
- add to cart
- Witch Ends
- $12.99
- Witch Ends are the parts of brownies that are on the edge of the pan. Some people think the drier edges are the best part. Witch Ends are great crumbled over ice cream or fruit. We have both Fat Witch and Caramel Witch Ends. Both delicious!
- Witch Brew
- $9.99
- Tiny bits of real chocolate melt into making the best hot chocolate ever.
- add to cart
-
- Original Fat Witch Brownie Mix
SOLD OUT
- $5.99
- This is my original recipe
Have fun baking and enjoy every magical morsel!
- Visit the Witch Kitchen for
baking tips and fun facts
- SOLD OUT
-
- Classic Cauldron Special
- $27.00
- This Take-Out box is loaded.
- 2 Fat, 2 Caramel,
2 Blonde, 2 Walnut
& 2 Double Chocolate Babies
- color of box and ribbon may vary. Shipment only -
No Store Pick Up.
- add to cart
- Cookie Witch
- $28
- 22 Chocolate Chip Cookies in a Witch Tin.
- Shipment only -
No Store Pick Up.
- add to cart
-
- Tote Bag
- $7.99
- You can use this bag over & over again. It's fun, practical and so New York!.
- add to cart
-
- Logo Mug
- $11.50
- It's a Mug to remember New York
- Hand wash recommended.
Microwave safe.
- add to cart
-
- Favors
- A favor makes your special occasion more memorable. We've sweetened up weddings, parties, birthdays, corporate events and celebrity Swag Bags.
- Information
-
Opt-in to the Fat Witch Newsletter for monthly discount codes, free offers and more
Submitting. Please wait...
Thank you! Check your email for promo code.
Product will stay fresh for 7-10 days at room temperature. Serve at room temperature.
If desired, refrigerate immediately for 3 weeks or freeze for 3 months.
Classic BUY NOW & Classic Cauldron Special always available. 
