Products

Our signature black-and-white Skyline Tin, filled with four baby-sized brownies—a perfect gift or treat for yourself!

Four little brownies packed into a cute tin—perfect for when you need a sweet pick-me-up.
Tiny but mighty in flavor!

Assorted Gift Box contains: 1 Fat Baby, 1 Blonde Baby, 1 Double Chocolate Baby &1 Snow Baby

Indulge in the rich flavors of our specialty coffee with our 5 pack selection. Perfect for coffee lovers, this assortment offers a delicious taste experience that will leave you wanting more. Each pack contains 5 individual servings, making it easy to enjoy a great cup of coffee at home or on-the-go.

Curious how to use our Drip Coffee? Watch the demo on our Instagram!

Can’t decide? Now you don’t have to! The 9 Baby All Star brings together 9 of our most beloved Baby Brownies so you can taste them all: 2 Fat Witch, plus Blonde, Double Chocolate, Caramel, Snow, Apple Cinnamon, Red, and Yuzu. Perfect for anyone who wants to discover their favorites—or simply enjoy a little bit of everything.

This little brownie’s got a nutty side—rich chocolate swirled with toasted almond slices and slivers for a bold, crunchy bite that’s anything but basic.

Sweet, spiced, and full of fall flavor, this brownie brings the warm taste of apple and cinnamon in every bite.

The perfect gift to say thank you.  The box is tied with ribbon and filled with delicious individually wrapped all chocolate brownies.  Small things come in good packages!

Find harmony in every bite. This beautifully curated gift features four Japanese-inspired Fat Witch Baby flavors: rich Fat Witch Original, nutty Sesame, earthy Matcha, and bright, citrusy Yuzu.

A sleek and modern set that’s perfect for thoughtful gifting—or your own moment of zen.

67 delicious recipes from your favorite bakery—perfect for your next bake sale, party, or just baking up some magic at home!

Sampler:
2 Fat Witch, Blonde Witch, Walnut Witch, Caramel Witch, Coffee Witch, Double Chocolate Witch, & Snow Witch.

Box of Favs:
2 Fat Witches, 1 Blonde Witch, 2 Walnut Witches, 2 Caramel Witches & 1 Double Chocolate Witch.

Chocolate Only:
8 of our legendary Fat Witch brownies.

The iconic logo on the box makes it a perfect gift… or just a treat-yourself moment.

Light, soft, and full of charm — the Blonde Baby blends vanilla richness with chunks of dark chocolate. It’s like a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie had the perfect bite-sized baby.

Rich brownie bites coated in a smooth layer of chocolate for an easy, satisfying treat. Simple, indulgent, and perfectly portioned, they’re great for snacking, sharing, or adding to a gift box. A little bite of chocolate happiness, anytime.

Bake the classic Fat Witch brownie at home! Rich and perfectly chocolatey, it’s the ultimate treat for cozy moments and homemade indulgence.

Build your own Fat Witch right from the comfort of your kitchen with 4 Baby Brownies, 2 Fat Witch Babies and 2 Snow Babies, plus mini jars of Coop’s Fudge and Coop’s Salted Caramel Sauce.

Assemble, decorate, drizzle, and enjoy your own delicious little witch creation. A fun, hands-on treat to enjoy with family and friends, anytime.

Smooth caramel meets classic brownie in every bite. Just 2-3 bites of sweet, gooey perfection that’ll keep you coming back for more.

The Caramel Witch swirls buttery caramel into rich chocolate brownie for a sweet, smooth finish in every bite.

A magical mix of 8 brownie babies—Fat, Caramel, Blonde, Walnut, and Double Chocolate—all wrapped up and ready to charm your taste buds!

Includes: 2 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Double Chocolate Babies, 1 Caramel Baby, 1 Walnut Baby.

The Coffee Witch is a mocha-lover’s dream — deep coffee flavor, dark chocolate chips, and brownie richness in perfect harmony.

Twice the chocolate, twice the fun! This brownie’s packed with rich chocolate and extra chips for a seriously delicious, can’t-stop-at-one kind of treat.

Twice the chocolate, twice the charm — the Double Chocolate Witch is a bold take on our classic.

Born from pure chocolate passion, our original brownie casts a rich, classic spell you just can’t resist.

This is where the magic began. Our original brownie — rich, satisfying, and deeply chocolatey — made for those moments when only a true classic will do.

A mug that captures the spirit of New York — classic, bold, and unmistakably Fat Witch.

The perfect everyday companion for fans of our legendary brownies.

Carry your goodies in style—with a bag that’s as fun and practical as New York itself! This bright yellow tote is perfect for everyday use and built to be reused again and again.

Size: 18" x 14" x 3"

A delicious mix of Fat Witch favorites! Our 16 Baby Halloween Box includes 8 Halloween Babies, plus 2 each of Pumpkin Caramel, Double Chocolate, Snow, Blonde Babies. A spooky-sweet assortment perfect for sharing and gifting!

A delicious taste of fall! Our Halloween 4 Baby Tin includes four seasonal favorites: Halloween Baby, Pumpkin Caramel Baby, Apple Cinnamon Baby, and Peanut Butter Baby, all packed in a special Halloween orange tin. A perfect treat for the season!

A spooky-season favorite! Our limited-edition Halloween Baby Witch is here for a limited time.

A spooky taste of fall! Our Halloween Cauldron is filled with two of each seasonal favorite: Pumpkin Caramel Baby, Apple Cinnamon Baby, and Peanut Butter Baby. A wickedly delicious assortment perfect for sharing and gifting!