10% OFF your first order
Sort by:
37 products
37 products
![Double Chocolate Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/DOUBLE-CHOCOLATE-WITCH.jpg?v=1753889896&width=1500)
![Double Chocolate Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/double_chocolate_back_label.jpg?v=1754409979&width=1500)
![Double Chocolate Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/DOUBLE_CHOCOLATE_BIG.jpg?v=1754408799&width=1500)
Twice the chocolate, twice the charm — the Double Chocolate Witch is a bold take on our classic.
![Caramel Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/CARAMEL_WITCH.jpg?v=1753371164&width=1500)
![Caramel Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/CARAMEL_BIG.jpg?v=1754315781&width=1500)
The Caramel Witch swirls buttery caramel into rich chocolate brownie for a sweet, smooth finish in every bite.
![Blonde Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/BLONDE-WITCH.jpg?v=1753889865&width=1500)
![Blonde Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/blonde_back_label.png?v=1754410023&width=1500)
![Blonde Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/Image_-_2025-08-07T162615.860.jpg?v=1754598434&width=1500)
![Fat Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/FAT-WITCH.jpg?v=1753889929&width=1500)
![Fat Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/FAT_WITCH_BIG.jpg?v=1754405634&width=1500)
![Fat Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/FW_back_label.png?v=1754409756&width=1500)
Born from pure chocolate passion, our original brownie casts a rich, classic spell you just can’t resist.
![Walnut Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/WALNUT-WITCH.jpg?v=1753890434&width=1500)
![Walnut Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/walnut_back_label.png?v=1754410087&width=1500)
The Walnut Witch is rich, chocolatey, and full of nutty charm. A classic brownie with hearty walnut pieces in every bite.
![Salted Caramel Baby [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/SALTED-CARAMEL-BABY.jpg?v=1762188384&width=1500)
A perfect balance of sweet caramel and a hint of sea salt in every bite.
![Apple Cinnamon Baby [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/APPLE-CINNAMON-BABY_normal.jpg?v=1762277571&width=1500)
Sweet, spiced, and full of fall flavor, this brownie brings the warm taste of apple and cinnamon in every bite.
Showing 37/37
Allergen Alert
Baked in a facility where nuts, wheat flour, milk, eggs, dairy, and chocolate are on premises. We do use some ingredients that are processed in factories that keep peanuts on premises.
Eggs
Dairy