10% OFF your first order
Sort by:
11 products
11 products
Can’t decide? Now you don’t have to! The 9 Baby All Star brings together 9 of our most beloved Baby Brownies so you can taste them all: 2 Fat Witch, plus Blonde, Double Chocolate, Caramel, Snow, Apple Cinnamon, Red, and Yuzu. Perfect for anyone who wants to discover their favorites—or simply enjoy a little bit of everything.
A tiny taste of spring! This Easter tin packs 4 seasonal Fat Witch Babies—Strawberry, Coconut, Lemon, and classic Fat Witch—perfectly nestled in a cute, springy tin that’s ready for gifting or enjoying right away.
Springtime sweetness, ready to gift! This Easter gift box features 8 seasonal Fat Witch Babies—Strawberry, Coconut, Lemon, and classic Fat Witch—beautifully presented in a sleek black box tied with a cheerful, springy ribbon. Perfect for sharing or treating someone special!
18 tiny bites of spring! This Easter tin is full of sweet surprises: 8 classic Fat Witch Babies, 2 Strawberry, 2 Coconut, 2 Lemon, 2 Blonde, and 2 Double Chocolate Babies—perfect for sharing, gifting, or indulging all on your own!
The perfect gift to say thank you. The box is tied with ribbon and filled with delicious individually wrapped all chocolate brownies. Small things come in good packages!
The perfect party favor! This mini gift comes with 1 Fat Witch Baby and 1 Blonde Baby, tucked inside our signature NYC Tiny Bag.
Includes: 1 Fat Witch Baby & 1 Blonde Baby.
Our signature black-and-white Skyline Tin, filled with four baby-sized brownies—a perfect gift or treat for yourself!
Four little brownies packed into a cute tin—perfect for when you need a sweet pick-me-up.
Tiny but mighty in flavor!
Assorted Gift Box contains: 1 Fat Baby, 1 Blonde Baby, 1 Double Chocolate Baby &1 Snow Baby
Find harmony in every bite. This beautifully curated gift features four Japanese-inspired Fat Witch Baby flavors: rich Fat Witch Original, nutty Sesame, earthy Matcha, and bright, citrusy Yuzu.
A sleek and modern set that’s perfect for thoughtful gifting—or your own moment of zen.
Sampler:
2 Fat Witch, Blonde Witch, Walnut Witch, Caramel Witch, Coffee Witch, Double Chocolate Witch, & Snow Witch.
Box of Favs:
2 Fat Witches, 1 Blonde Witch, 2 Walnut Witches, 2 Caramel Witches & 1 Double Chocolate Witch.
Chocolate Only:
8 of our legendary Fat Witch brownies.
The iconic logo on the box makes it a perfect gift… or just a treat-yourself moment.
A magical mix of 8 brownie babies—Fat, Caramel, Blonde, Walnut, and Double Chocolate—all wrapped up and ready to charm your taste buds!
Includes: 2 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Double Chocolate Babies, 1 Caramel Baby, 1 Walnut Baby.
A magical treat in every bag! Each of the 8 tiny bags contains 2 assorted baby brownies, packed with our signature flavors. Perfect for sharing, gifting, or enjoying a little brownie magic, these bags bring joy in every bite!
The tiny bags in total contain: 8 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Walnut Babies, 2 Caramel Babies, 2 Snow Babies
Shipment only, no store pickup!
Allergen Alert
Baked in a facility where nuts, wheat flour, milk, eggs, dairy, and chocolate are on premises. We do use some ingredients that are processed in factories that keep peanuts on premises.
Eggs
Dairy