10% OFF your first order
Sort by:
34 products
34 products
![Snow Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/SNOW_WITCH_2aeeb6c2-6e60-4949-b072-6cbf37aca652.jpg?v=1753890767&width=1500)
![Snow Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/snow_back_label.png?v=1754409992&width=1500)
The Snow Witch is smooth, sweet, and full of white chocolate magic — a creamy twist on our classic that’s impossible to resist.
![Coffee Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/COFFEE-WITCH.jpg?v=1753889878&width=1500)
![Coffee Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/coffee_back_label.png?v=1754410060&width=1500)
The Coffee Witch is a mocha-lover’s dream — deep coffee flavor, dark chocolate chips, and brownie richness in perfect harmony.
![Emerald City Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/EMERALD-CITY-WITCH.jpg?v=1753890232&width=1500)
![Emerald City Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/emerald_back_label.jpg?v=1754410047&width=1500)
Bright, minty, and full of chocolatey goodness—the Emerald City Witch is a lively, green-hued treat that brings a fresh spark to every bite.
![Walnut Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/WALNUT-WITCH.jpg?v=1753890434&width=1500)
![Walnut Witch [cyo]](http://www.fatwitch.com/cdn/shop/files/walnut_back_label.png?v=1754410087&width=1500)
The Walnut Witch is rich, chocolatey, and full of nutty charm. A classic brownie with hearty walnut pieces in every bite.
Showing 34/34
Allergen Alert
Baked in a facility where nuts, wheat flour, milk, eggs, dairy, and chocolate are on premises. We do use some ingredients that are processed in factories that keep peanuts on premises.
Eggs
Dairy